Do you prefer revolvers or automatics?

[moon walker]

I was at the range last week, switching between my Ruger GP100 and a friend’s small auto. It made me think about how each gun changes your rhythm. The revolver makes me slow down but the auto makes me speed up. What do you prefer?

 

[ButchA]

Depends on the situation: My two favorites are seen below:

I am a longtime fan of the legendary 1911 ever since USCG bootcamp in the late 70's! I knew that once I settled down, retired, etc... I just HAD to own one! Now, being that it is (avg) 2.5 lbs carry weight, it's a bit much for an IWB holster, so I carry it in a replica M3 Tanker holster. For the ultimate CWP, I bid on and won an original 1972 S&W Mod 36 .38 snubby, that was (according to the FFL dealer) a real LEO's piece based out of Ocala, FL! I can toss the little snubby in a pocket, in a IWB holster, anywhere.... and nobody would know a thing!

 

[Steve]

Each pistol has its rhythm. My revolver makes me take my time but autos are faster. I like revolvers a bit more but both feel good in hand.

 

[foxfirerodandgun]

I have always leaned towards a revolver for self-defense because of its reliability and less chance of a failure to feed, eject, or rapidly fire a second round after a misfire/dead round. The downside is limited round capacity. However, in a real-world self-defense scenario, is 15-18 rounds really necessary, especially for a person who knows their weapon and is proficient with it?

 

[Alpha]

I keep switching back and forth between revolvers and autos, and I still reach for a revolver when I want a slower, more relaxed rhythm. The simplicity just feels right but autos definitely keep me moving, especially when I'm doing drills or chasing faster times.

 

[JIM]

Quick question... When you switch between a revolver and an auto, do you notice your accuracy change, or does your muscle memory stay consistent? I always feel my pace change, which always makes me laugh

 

[Surrywoodman]

I waffle back and forth between autos and revolvers too. For me, when I switch, there is a period of time when I have to adjust to the difference in ergonomics and rhythm.

 

[Virginia 01]

I do not prefer one over the other. They each have their place and time. So the answer is, it depends....